In 1969, Minsky & Papert showed that two-layered neural nets couldn’t learn to determine whether a figure was connected or not. Fast forward to 2024, with vastly more data, layers & compute, and neural nets (as we now know how to make them) still fail at some really basic stuff:
@garymarcus
-
Gary Marcus addresses misinformation and social media dynamics
By
–
That Gary Marcus cares a lot about misinformation and the distorted dynamics of social media. Like almost everyone else he awaits accurate information about motive.
-
LeCun Elon debate ad hominem arguments AI discussion
By
–
It’s not “slightly” ad hominem to change the topic from aging to someone’s possible substance abuse problem. I am no Elon fan boy but seriously tired of LeCun frequent retreats to ad hominem.
-
Sora AI video generation consistency physics comparison debate
By
–
I guess that is a new video? But sora which definitely does not have consistent physics has a nearly identical video 4 months ago: https://
youtu.be/o5wAMFadDic?si
=XSbkZvbdi3yqFGZH
… -
Company Retracts AGI Claims, Reports Level 2 Progress Only
By
–
I think they said they are nearing (not at) level 2 and didn’t even use the term AGI afaik? definitely a retrenchment from jokes about “AGI has been achieved internally” and some of other public statements they made.
-
AI Hype Cycle: Why LLMs Won’t Achieve AGI Alone
By
–
https://
garymarcus.substack.com/p/the-great-ai
-retrenchment-has-begun
… “It was always going to happen; the ludicrously high expectations from last 18 ChatGPT-drenched months were never going to be met. LLMs are not AGI, and (on their own) never will be; scaling alone was never going to be enough. The only mystery was what -
AI Retrenchment Signals Growing Market Consolidation Trend
By
–
Still further signs of the Great AI Retrenchment.
-
The Great AI Retrenchment Has Begun Analysis
By
–
https://
open.substack.com/pub/garymarcus
/p/the-great-ai-retrenchment-has-begun?r=8tdk6&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web
… -
AI Regulatory Requirements Compared to Automotive Standards
By
–
What exactly makes the requirements impossible to comply with! In what way they are worse than the requirements in eg automotive which many manufacturers routinely meet? Please be specific.
-
AGI Definition and Criteria: Community Vetted Standards
By
–
People keep complaining that there is no definition and criteria for AGI. That’s not true. I actually gave some in 2023, in a bet I proposed to Elon Musk, & vetted with the community, including two of people that helped coined the term, and *there was a large degree of