I'm sympathetic to the idea that tools can assist people, and I understand that you don't think anyone can learn Art (though it's wrong). However, why not promote legal and ethical implementations rather than create misguided campaigns to plaster over genuine complaints?
@alexjc
-
AI Companies’ Illegal Data Strategy Destroys Industries Deliberately
By
–
They don't want to put any time or effort into the data sourcing, and finding public domain works is hard! It's their intentional strategy, break the law and by the time authorities catch up they've destroyed entire industries and their best practices…
-
AI Copyright Rights and Union Representation in Court
By
–
That's assuming, worst case, the courts make a special case for AI not following Copyright to industry standards. But any union that represents people with 2m images should be listened to as joint authors with full rights respected…
-
AI Training Data Attribution and Compensation Challenges
By
–
I found similar numbers for the largest AAA games, like 3617 for Assassin's Creed Unity. Even if they were to credit and compensate at that level of granularity, 1/3617th — that'd imply handling any website / company / union / org above 1.5m images.
-
Dataset Contributions and Legal Credit Recognition in AI
By
–
Thought so. The decision of ignoring someone's contribution to a dataset because there are so many other contributions, would be a new legal theory unfounded in industry practice. Do you know what movie has the most people credited?
-
Artist Copyright Rights in AI-Generated Animated Content
By
–
Say you're an artist that contributes one single shot to an animated movie. One out of 2h movie total. Can the studio afford to ignore your contribution / copyright / contract / payment? Below what percentage of a single shot could you be ignored?
-
DMCA Action Against AI Project Circumventing Copy Protection
By
–
DMCA the project on the basis that it circumvents copy protection.
-
Anthropomorphic Arguments Against AI Copyright Infringement
By
–
Need to think of some reverse arguments that are also anthropomorphic… "If a human pirated books like that it'd be infringement too."
-
Data-mining campaigns use anthropomorphism to manipulate public opinion
By
–
A previous campaign on data-mining that used anthropomorphisms succeeded. It helps convince people who don't know better…
-
Economic Rights vs Mass IP Infringement Legal Analysis
By
–
Do individual lose their economic and moral rights when an opposing party is taking the rights away from so many other people it doesn't count anymore? That's equally unsupported by the law. (Copying is substantial, 100% of the works are copied.)