?? There are many rights within Copyright, and all of those can be infringed. A sample can infringe because of the Right Of Reproduction, Right To Distribute — it does not necessarily imply the Right To Make Derivatives was infringed.
@alexjc
-
AI Model Copyright Rulings: Derivative Works and Fair Use
By
–
In the AI rulings so far, some of the judges explicitly ruled out the "models as derivative" claims because the amount copied by models was minor and it didn't fit the usual definition of derivatives. That suggests small quotes don't count. Do you have ruling or caselaw?
-
Warhol Case Analysis: Reconciling Copyright Infringement Theory
By
–
Another inconsistency in your original take: you posted about this case yesterday, but it seems to invalidate your theory as well. (Warhol would also be infringing using this analysis.) How do you reconcile the two?
-
AWF Supreme Court: Unauthorized Derivatives and Fair Use Assessment
By
–
The perspective from the AWF Supreme Court ruling suggests that the "state" of the painting as infringing (or not) doesn't matter, only "uses" or actions do. And all of them must be reassessed according to four factors. Such is the burden of making an unauthorized derivative!
-
AI-Generated Art and Copyright: Fair Use Limitations Explained
By
–
The Warhol painting is an unauthorized derivative that doesn't even qualify for © protection (Anderson v. Stallone). Certain uses can be considered Fair Use, but others are not… at anytime and for any use, Goldsmith can object and seek remedies.
-
Copyright Attribution and Derivative Works in Creative AI
By
–
Unless you quote a huge part you're not making a derivative, it's just a quote. A better example is a cover song, which is generally considered a derivative in music today. Standard practice is to include the original author in the credits, and attribute/pay them accordingly.
-
Fair Use for AI Derivatives: Legal Boundaries and Licensing Markets
By
–
You agree it's a derivative, but claim all downstream uses except licensing in the same market are covered by "Fair Use"?
-
Intellectual Property Dispute in Digital Market Competition
By
–
At this stage it's just bad faith arguing? You must know the context by now. Defendant also sold their work in the same market as plaintiff.
-
LLMs Automating Well-Defined Tasks and Front-End Code
By
–
I suspect that well-defined tasks that can be posted to Fiverr or have a clear set of success conditions (e.g. make a custom WordPress plugin) are not far from being "automated" if that's how you think about it. Front-end code is already very LLM-suited!
-
AlphaTensor: Novel Matrix Multiplication Discovery and Security Automation
By
–
That said, here's an example of inventing new matrix multiplication (do your homework): https://
deepmind.google/discover/blog/
discovering-novel-algorithms-with-alphatensor/
… Plus, security vulnerabilities are found routinely (and by default) with automated tools on all serious projects.