The most prominent academic society in my field (the Academy of Management) prohibits AI use in reviews, when the evidence suggests it should be mandatory to run AI reviews (with human discretion, of course). https://
elliottash.com/wp-content/upl
oads/2026/04/Kohler-Zollikofer-Einsiedler-Hoyle-Ash-Read-Paper-Write-Code-Agentic-Reproduction-Social-Science-Results.pdf
…
Academic Society Prohibits AI Reviews Despite Evidence for Mandatory Use
By
–